Research Article
Print
Research Article
Ontogeny of the ptychopariid trilobite Kaotaia globosa from the Cambrian Kaili Biota of eastern Guizhou, China
expand article infoShengguang Chen‡§|, Dezhi Wang|§‡, Zhixin Sun#, Zhengpeng Chen¤, Xinglian Yang|§‡, Fangchen Zhao#
‡ College of Resource and Environmental Engineering, Guizhou University, Guiyang, China
§ Key Laboratory of Karst Georesources and Environment (Guizhou University), Ministry of Education, Guiyang, China
| Guizhou Provincial Key Laboratory for Palaeontology and Palaeoenvironment, Guiyang, China
¶ State Key Laboratory of Palaeobiology and Stratigraphy, Nanjing Institute of Geology and Palaeontology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, Nanjing, China
# College of Earth and Planetary Sciences, University of Chinese Academy of Sciences, Beijing, China
¤ School of Biological Sciences and Technology, Liupanshui Normal University, Liupanshui, China
Open Access

Abstract

The exceptional fossil record of trilobite ontogeny allows the elucidation of the developmental evolution of early arthropods. However, the paucity of detailed segmental growth data limits the understanding of growth dynamics during post-embryonic development. Rich trilobite material is preserved in the Cambrian Kaili Biota (Miaolingian Series, Wuliuan Stage), and many articulated specimens of the “ptychopariid” Kaotaia globosa Chang & Zhou in Lu et al., 1974, from a relatively narrow stratigraphic interval provide valuable opportunities for a detailed ontogenetic study. This study documents the ontogenetic sequence and phenotypic changes of K. globosa from meraspid degree 3 to the holaspid period, integrating traditional morphological descriptions and geometric morphometric analyses. Analyses revealed that the primary changes in the K. globosa cranidium during ontogeny occurred in the glabella, facial suture, and palpebral lobes. The trunk of K. globosa follows a hemianamorphic pattern with a protomeric developmental mode. Growth model fitting suggests that the trunk-segment growth rate of K. globosa is controlled by a growth field (TGmold), which exhibits a continuously increasing growth gradient from front to back. A comprehensive analysis of existing data revealed significant variation in holaspid exoskeletal length, suggesting that an increasing growth gradient may have enabled these trilobites to undergo shorter anamorphic development followed by prolonged epimorphic development for body-size increase.

Keywords

Developmental mode, growth control mechanisms, quantitative morphometrics, trilobite, trunk growth gradient

Introduction

Trilobites are frequently regarded as a paradigm for comprehending the Cambrian explosion of animal life, owing to their unparalleled diversity and abundance (Paterson et al. 2019). The fossil record indicates that the highly biomineralized exoskeletons of trilobites were already present at early post-embryonic stages (Speyer and Chatterton 1989; Hughes 2003; Hopkins 2017; Hughes et al. 2017), providing indispensable empirical evidence for research into metamorphosis (e.g., Chatterton 1980; Minelli et al. 2003; Hughes et al. 2006; Laibl et al. 2023), ecological adaptation (e.g., Speyer and Chatterton 1989; Fusco et al. 2004; Crônier et al. 2011), heterochrony (e.g., McNamara 1986a, 1986b; Webster et al. 2001; Hunda and Hughes 2007; Webster and Zelditch 2011), and macroevolution (e.g., Fortey and Chatterton 1988; Adrain et al. 1998; Webster 2007a; Paterson et al. 2019; Sun et al. 2025) of early arthropod groups. Trilobites have among the most complete ontogenetic records of any extinct group (Hughes 2003, 2007), and their exoskeletons grow in a manner similar to that of other arthropods, in a stepwise manner paced by the molting cycle (Fusco et al. 2012, 2016). During trilobite ontogeny, both the number of expressed segments and the articulation between segments in the trunk underwent a series of dynamic changes (Fusco et al. 2012), while the release and expression of trunk segments varied between species (Hughes et al. 2006, 2017). Meanwhile, the emergence of biological diversity in trilobites is closely linked to changes in ontogenetic series; studies of ontogeny not only reveal changes in species diversity but also provide evidence regarding the phylogenetically basal developmental character states of major clades (Fusco et al. 2012).

Traditional research into trilobite ontogeny has mainly centered on describing developmental stages and the resulting morphological differences (e.g., McNamara et al. 2006; Lei 2016; Dai et al. 2017). Quantitative morphological analysis of many specimens spanning multiple developmental stages, however, facilitates the elucidation of the intrinsic mechanisms controlling growth (Hughes et al. 2017). In recent years, geometric morphometrics has been widely employed to investigate inter- and intraspecific variation (Esteve 2012; Jackson and Budd 2017; Álvaro et al. 2018; Chen et al. 2022) and ontogeny (Delabroye and Crônier 2008; Hong et al. 2014; Webster 2015; Hopkins and Pearson 2016; Jacobs and Carlucci 2019) in trilobites. The application of geometric morphometrics not only presents morphological changes during trilobite ontogeny in a more intuitive manner but also reveals subtle variations that are often overlooked in traditional descriptions. Drawing on 2D landmarks, Webster (2007b) revealed the nature of morphological differences between Nephrolenellus multinodus and its sister taxon N. geniculatus, as well as how these differences arise during ontogeny. Hopkins and Pearson (2016) went a step further by conducting three-dimensional geometric morphometric analyses of silicified Cryptolithus tesselatus specimens based on CT scan results, thereby capturing variations in cephalon convexity during development that could not be detected using 2D landmarks.

Changes in growth gradients, as reflected by the relative sizes of trunk segments, are evident, but elucidating the mechanisms controlling segment growth requires precise morphometric analysis (Fusco et al. 2014). The Silurian trilobite Aulacopleura koninckii represents a significant subject for ontogenetic studies, with researchers having conducted extensive investigations into its growth and developmental processes (Hughes and Chapman 1995; Fusco et al. 2004, 2014, 2016; Hong et al. 2014; Hughes et al. 2017). In their study, to investigate how changes to the trunk growth gradient were realized during development, Fusco et al. (2014) proposed two hypotheses for controlling trilobite segment development: the Segmental Gradient Hypothesis (SGH) and the Trunk Gradient Hypothesis (TGH). The former suggested individualized per-segment growth rates, and the latter saw the trunk as a unified developmental field in which segment growth responded to position within the field. By extending the approach used in A. koninckii to other trilobites, it will be possible to determine the developmental controls that are retained among all members of the clade, as well as those that vary within the clade (see Hughes et al. 2017). Through the use of growth stages that closely correlate with the molting cycle as explanatory variables for trunk segmentation patterns, researchers have detected an anterior-to-posterior progressively increasing axial growth gradient in several additional trilobite trunks and investigated the mechanism controlling segment growth (Du et al. 2019; Hopkins 2021; Dai et al. 2021a; Holmes et al. 2021a).

Although significant progress has been made in trilobite ontogenetic studies, complete or nearly complete ontogenetic sequences for “ptychopariids” remain scarce compared to those of other groups (e.g., Stubblefield 1926; Fortey and Owens 1991; Bird and Clarkson 2003; Hopkins 2021). Early “ptychopariids” are considered to contain the ancestors of several highly apomorphic post-Cambrian trilobite clades (Fortey 2001; Sun et al. 2020). Systematically summarizing “ptychopariid” ontogenetic information may further the understanding of the characteristics of basal nodes among derived Trilobita. Here, the authors describe a nearly complete ontogenetic sequence based on numerous specimens of the “ptychopariid” trilobite Kaotaia globosa from the Cambrian Kaili Biota of eastern Guizhou, China, which illustrates the morphological changes during ontogeny. Quantitative morphological analysis is further employed to examine growth control in the developing trunk. Studying trilobite ontogeny not only reveals the trends of morphological change and growth regulatory mechanisms during ontogeny but also deepens the understanding of this once-dominant group, which existed from Cambrian Series 2 to the end of the Permian, spanning almost the entire Paleozoic, approximately 270 million years.

Geological setting

The study area is situated in the southeastern part of Jianhe County, Guizhou Province, China, at 26°45.014'N, 108°24.982'E (Fig. 1). The Kaili Formation in the Miaobanpo section is in unconformable contact with the dolostone of the Tsinghsutung Formation (Cambrian Stage 4) and is overlain by the argillaceous limestone of the Jialao Formation (Miaolingian Series, Wuliuan Stage) (Yuan et al. 2002). Detailed measurements show that the Kaili Formation of the Miaobanpo section is divided into 27 beds based on lithological characteristics, with a total thickness of 156.05 m, and lithologically alternates among silty mudstone, calcareous mudstone, and a set of terrigenous clastic rocks dominated by shale, with limestone at the top and bottom (Zhou et al. 1979; Yin 1987; Zhao et al. 2019). The Kaili Formation is generally considered to have been deposited in a slope environment with a high sedimentation rate, below the storm-wave base and near the redox interface, with two microfacies depositional models, calcareous claystone facies and carbonate mudstone facies (Zhang et al. 1996; Zhu et al. 1999; Gaines et al. 2011). The abundance of macroalgae with holdfasts (Wu et al. 2016), echinoderms attached to biological debris (Lin et al. 2008; Liu et al. 2023), trace fossils (Wang et al. 2009), and trilobite exuviae (Chen et al. 2023) further indicates that the Kaili Formation was deposited under low-energy conditions below the storm-wave base and was dominated by multiphase sedimentation (Gaines et al. 2011). Within the Kaili Formation, the following trilobite zones are represented from the bottom upward: 1) Bathynotus kueichouensis–Ovatoryctocara sinensis Assemblage-Zone; 2) Oryctocephalus indicus Zone; and 3) Peronopsis taijiangensis Zone (Zhao et al. 2012, 2019).

Figure 1. 

Location and geological survey of the research area. A. Regional map showing the location of the research area; B. Lithofacies reconstruction of South China during the earliest Miaolingian Epoch (modified from Feng et al. 2004), with a red asterisk in the shale basin facies indicating the location of the Kaili Biota; C. Geological map of part of Balang Village, showing the study area and location of the Miaobanpo section (modified from Zhao et al. 2019); D. Stratigraphic column of the Kaili Formation from the Miaobanpo section (modified from Zhao et al. 2012).

Materials and methods

Materials

The specimens of the trilobite Kaotaia globosa were collected from the Kaili Formation of the Miaobanpo section, mainly from the 9th bed (indicated by specimen number GTBM9) and the 17th bed (indicated by specimen number GTBM17). The authors selected 136 internal molds and nine external molds, with minimal evidence of postmortem distortion, as the objects of study in this paper. A total of 145 specimens are deposited at the Guizhou Provincial Key Laboratory for Paleontology and Paleoenvironment. Detailed sample numbers and measurements are provided in Suppl. materials 1, 2, respectively.

Methods

To eliminate color differences between the fossils and highlight subtle structural features, the fossils were coated with magnesium oxide before being photographed with a Canon 5D Mark IV camera and a VHX100K microscope. The approach of landmark-based geometric morphometrics aims to summarize the pattern of change in biomorphology via extracting the morphological information contained in landmarks (Bookstein 1991; Rohlf and Marcus 1993; Zelditch et al. 2004). Compared with the complex trunk homology arising from segmental exchange between the meraspid pygidium and the thorax, the structures associated with the cranidial furrows and the facial suture of trilobites are readily discernible and can be considered homologous. Consequently, research into the ontogenetic and evolutionary biology of trilobites has primarily centered on the characteristics of their cephalon (Jacobs and Carlucci 2019). The tpsUtil and tpsDig v.216 software (Rohlf 2010) were used to measure specific parts of the Kaotaia globosa cephalon and obtain coordinates for 19 landmark points (Fig. 2). The specimens examined in this paper are well preserved and minimally affected by deformation, which enabled the acquisition of data from 19 landmarks across all specimens. The collected raw morphological coordinate data (Suppl. material 1) were imported into PAST software (Hammer et al. 2001) to generate a variance-covariance matrix, and partial Procrustes superimposition was performed on the morphological coordinate data of each sample to eliminate the influence of non-shape differences.

Figure 2. 

Reconstruction of Kaotaia globosa showing landmarks selected for morphometric analyses. A. Locations of cephalic landmarks for analyzed specimens; B. Reconstruction of K. globosa is based on specimen GTBM 9-1-6016, and the red dots are the 19 landmarks selected for morphometric analysis in the cephalic region. Abbreviations: BOL, body length; CEL, cephalic axial length; TRL, trunk length; PYL, pygidial length; LTSi, length of each thoracic segment i.

Through regression transformation, principal component analysis (PCA) simplifies multidimensional data into fewer composite variables, with new axes accounting for maximum original variability (Quinn and Keough 2002). Applying this method, a PCA was conducted based on landmark data from the detailed ontogenetic sequence of Kaotaia globosa. Accurate stratigraphic occurrence data afford the opportunity to examine the partitioning of variation among collections with modest environmental or temporal differences (Hughes et al. 2021). In this study, the inclusion of specimens from both bed 9 and bed 17 introduces a potential confounding factor, as inter-bed differences may constrain interpretation (Hughes et al. 2021). Although these two stratigraphic beds have similar petrological characteristics, combining specimens from different beds within the dataset is an unfortunate and unsatisfactory phenomenon. To assess this potential issue, a PCA was conducted on the holaspid specimens of K. globosa from different beds, concluding that their morphological characteristics exhibit minimal variation (see Suppl. material 3: fig. S1).

Fusco et al. (2012, 2014) proposed formulas for the average per-molt growth rate (AGR; absolute growth rate) and the allometry coefficient (relative growth rate) of trilobite segments. They defined the AGR as the antilogarithm of the average per-molt growth increment (AGI). The AGI of stage i (AGIi) is equal to the mean natural logarithm of developmental stage i minus the mean natural logarithm of developmental stage 1 in the ontogenetic sequence and divided by the value of stage i minus 1. The allometry coefficient is defined as the slope of a least-squares linear regression of ln (LTSi,d) on ln (TRLd) (Fusco et al. 2012, 2014). Based on observed values of the thoracic segment relative to trunk length (RLS) in Aulacopleura koninckii, Fusco et al. (2014) further proposed the Segmental Gradient Hypothesis (SGH) and Trunk Gradient Hypothesis (TGH) to explain the control of segmental growth. To quantify these hypotheses, they established two growth models for SGH (geometric series function, SGgmp; power series function, SGpwp) and two for TGH (exponential function, TGexp; power law function, TGpwl). Among these, the SGH postulates that each segment released into the thorax has a constant growth rate, with its final size determined by its relative position in the sequence, and that each segment exhibits distinct autonomous growth progression (Fusco et al. 2014). Alternatively, the TGH assumes a continuous and stable trunk growth gradient, which is determined by the differing growth rates at each position along the trunk (Fusco et al. 2014).

Taphonomic compaction affects fossil morphology in both the horizontal and vertical planes, which can exaggerate the estimated magnitude of shape changes and modify the observed patterns of shape change (Webster 2007b). Although the trilobite specimens here experienced minimal taphonomic distortion, the axial ring of Kaotaia globosa is not exactly at the same level as the pleurae, resulting in a poor match between the axial ring length and pleural length (sag.). Therefore, a transverse line connecting the fulcra on both sides of each segment was drawn and used to measure the length of the thoracic segments (Fig. 2B). To eliminate the effects of measurement error, each segment was measured twice, with the mean value used for analysis. The generated images were digitized using the ImageJ software package (Schneider et al. 2012) to obtain the length of a given structure (sag.) by measuring the distance between different line segments and to generate Suppl. material 2, a section of measurements that will be used to study the growth of the thoracic segments of K. globosa. In this approach, the slight overlap between the posterior edge of the occipital ring and the anterior end of the first thoracic segment (TS1) results in the measured cephalon length (sag.) being slightly smaller than the actual value, which in this paper is approximated as equal to the body length minus the trunk length. The number of thoracic and pygidial segments was determined by placing specimens under a stereomicroscope and examining them several times to ensure maximum accuracy. The calculations and subsequent statistical tests pertaining to trunk segment growth were conducted using Microsoft Excel 2010 and Statgraphics Centurion, Version XVI. Additionally, CorelDRAW 2017 (a free trial version) and Origin 2020 were employed in the graphical representation of the findings.

Systematic Paleontology

Terminology

The morphological terms and abbreviations used in the description generally follow Whittington and Kelly (1997). The classification criteria are principally derived from the scheme proposed by Fortey (1997). Abbreviations used in the descriptions include sag. = sagittal, exsag. = exsagittal, tr. = transverse, and S1–S3 = glabellar furrows 1 to 3.

Class Trilobita Walch, 1771

Order Ptychopariida Swinnerton, 1915

Family Alokistocaridae Resser, 1939

Kaotaia Lu, 1962

Type species.

Alokistococare magnum Lu, 1945. p. 195, pl. I, figs 3, 3a–j.

Kaotaia globosa Chang et Zhou in Lu et al., 1974

Figs 3, 5

Kaotaia globosa – Chang et Zhou in Lu et al. 1974, p. 99, pl. 38, fig. 9.

Kaotaia globosa – Yin et al. 1978, p. 466, pl. 160, fig. 2.

Kaotaia globosa – Zhang et al. 1980, p. 336, pl. 112, figs 3a, 4, 6, 7.

Kaotaia globosa – Huang et Zhao 1990, p. 342, pl. I, figs 2–5.

Kaotaia globosa – Yuan et Zhao 1994, p. 284–285, pl. I, figs 5, 6; pl. II, figs 3–7; pl. III, figs 2–5.

Kaotaia globosa – Fortey et Hughes, 1998, p. 644–645, fig. 1.4.

Kaotaia (Kaotaia) globosa – Yuan et al. 2002, p. 191, pl. 58, figs 5–8, pl. 59, figs 1, 2.

Holotype.

Cranidium, NIGP 21496 (housed in the Nanjing Institute of Geology and Palaeontology, Chinese Academy of Sciences, China) from the Kaili Formation, Nangao, eastern Guizhou, South China.

Figure 3. 

Meraspid exoskeletons of trilobite Kaotaia globosa from the Cambrian Kaili Biota (Miaolingian Series, Wuliuan Stage) of eastern Guizhou, China. A, B. Meraspid degree 3, with five pygidial segments (GTBM17-1-252; GTBM17-1962); C. Meraspid degree 4, with five pygidial segments (GTBM17-1-578); D. Meraspid degree 5, with four pygidial segments (GTBM9-5-1751); E. Meraspid degree 6, with four pygidial segments (GTBM17-2519); F. Meraspid degree 7, with four pygidial segments (GTBM 9-2-785); G–I. Meraspid degree 8, with four pygidial segments (GTBM17-2452; GTBM17-2865; GTBM20-5-1080); J. Meraspid degree 9, with three pygidial segments (GTBM17-1783); K, L. Meraspid degree 10, with three pygidial segments (GTBM9-4-2944; GTBM9-4-2945, external mold); M, N. Meraspid degree 11, with three pygidial segments (GTBM9-3-3780; GTBM17-1991). The arrows indicate the position of the boundary between the thorax and pygidium regions. Scale bars: 1 mm.

Figure 4. 

Reconstruction of the ontogenetic sequence from meraspid degree 3 to the holaspid stage of Kaotaia globosa based on specimens.

Figure 5. 

Meraspid and holaspid exoskeletons of trilobite Kaotaia globosa from the Cambrian Kaili Biota (Miaolingian Series, Wuliuan Stage) of eastern Guizhou, China. A–C. Meraspid degree 12 (specimen numbers are in the following order: GTBM9-2-1399, external mold; GTBM9-2-136; GTBM9-5-3794); D–F. Meraspid degree 13 (specimen numbers are in the following order: GTBM9-3-1052; GTBM9-2-1701; GTBM17-1-25290); G–L. Holaspid period (specimen numbers are in the following order: GTBM9-1-427, external mold; GTBM9-1-601; GTBM9-1-601b, external mold; GTBM9-5-5970; GTBM9-4-21038; GTBM17-419). The arrows indicate the position of the boundary between the thorax and pygidium regions. Scale bars: 1 mm.

Occurrence.

Cambrian Miaolingian Series, Wuliuan Stage, Oryctocephalus indicus Zone, Kaili Formation, Guizhou, China.

Material.

362 specimens, of which 145 were used in this study.

Description.

Holaspid cephalon semicircular; librigenal spine slender, terminating opposite eighth thoracic segment; cranidium sub-rectangular (except for posterior border), slightly less long than width between palpebral lobe midpoints or both subequal; glabella convex, truncate-conical, anterior margin flat-rounded; three pairs of shallow lateral glabellar furrows, S3 slightly obliquely extending posteriorly opposite eye ridge; S2 directed transverse, in the middle of the glabella; S1 bifurcated, directed posteriorly; occipital furrow shallow, transverse in middle, slightly deeper and slightly curved forward adaxially; occipital ring raised, slightly longer (sag.) in middle than adaxially, occipital node faint; preglabellar field long (sag.), with inflated boss; anterior border short (sag.) and gently convex, approximately half preglabellar field length (sag.); border furrow deep; fixigena broad (tr.), approximately 2/3 of glabellar width between palpebral lobes; posterior border of medium width (tr.) and length (exsag.), projecting outward slightly more than width of base of LO; posterior marginal furrow broad (exsag.), slightly arched forwards in middle; ocular ridge clearly defined, projecting outward from frontal lobe of glabella slightly obliquely posteriorly and parallel to border furrow; arcuate palpebral lobe moderately small, opposite glabellar midpoint, approximately 1/2 of glabellar length; anterior branch of facial suture extends outwardly arc forward to the border furrow turning inward to obliquely cut the anterior border; posterior branch of facial suture laterally and retro-posteriorly in a slight arc.

Librigenae narrow (tr.) and long (exsag.), transverse width of librigenal area greater than width of lateral border; border furrows deep, lateral furrows does not confluence with the posterior border furrows; lateral border narrow and slightly flat.

Rostral plate subrectangular, longest (sag.) medially; wider (tr.) than the frontal lobe, approximately as long (sag.) as the anterior border. An ovoid and natant hypostome known from some adult individuals.

Holaspid thorax slightly longer than cephalon, divided into 14 segments. Thoracic axis convex, narrowing by posterior constriction; pleura terminated by short, thick, falcate, backward-curving pleural spine; Pleural furrow deep, form posteriorly bent and narrow lenticular furrows, extending into the pleural spines.

Holaspid pygidium very small, transverse width equal to or less than width of base of glabella; pygidial axis short and broad, length slightly less than 2/3 of pygidium length, divided into 2 segments, pleural rib narrow, gently convex, pleural furrows firmly incised, interpleural furrows weakly incised.

Result

Description of ontogeny

The ontogenetic sequence of Kaotaia globosa Chang et Zhou in Lu et al., 1974, described herein ranges from meraspid degree 3 to the holaspid period (Figs 3, 4, 5); the number and size range of specimens at each stage are shown in Table 1. Ontogenetic stages of trilobites have traditionally been recognized on the basis of the development of exoskeletal segmentation, and the division of each phase relates specifically to the development of articulated joints between exoskeletal elements (Hughes et al. 2006). Therefore, in this paper, the ontogenetic sequence of meraspid degrees is based on an ascending number of thoracic segments, whereas the holaspid period includes all individuals that have reached the stable and mature number of thoracic segments, which in this species is 14. The main morphological variations are as follow:

Table 1.

Number of specimens and length range of the exoskeleton of Kaotaia globosa at each ontogenetic stage.

Ontogenetic stages Number of specimens Length range of exoskeleton (mm)
Meraspid degree 3 3 1.53–1.60
Meraspid degree 4 2 1.86–2.27
Meraspid degree 5 3 2.09–2.32
Meraspid degree 6 4 2.50–2.63
Meraspid degree 7 5 2.47–3.06
Meraspid degree 8 5 2.67–3.50
Meraspid degree 9 5 2.92–3.91
Meraspid degree 10 9 3.55–4.31
Meraspid degree 11 13 3.61–5.70
Meraspid degree 12 11 4.24–6.02
Meraspid degree 13 15 3.57–9.39
Holaspid stage 70 4.88–18.48

Meraspid degree 3

Represented by three articulated specimens, with two specimens illustrated (Fig. 3A, B), shields of this phase range from 1.53 to 1.60 mm in length, with the thorax having three segments and the pygidial axis having five segments (morph; m35, morphological conditions are indicated as mxy, where x is the number of thoracic segments and y is the number of pygidial segments, without the terminal piece). Cranidium semicircular, length (sag.) less than width between the midpoint of the two palpebral lobes (tr.); glabella convex, long columnar, glabellar furrows extremely indistinct; occipital furrow shallow and straight in the middle, slightly deeper and curved forward on both sides; occipital ring wider in the middle than on both sides (sag.); librigenal spine long and slender, extending to the posterior part of the pygidium; preglabellar field broad (sag.), with a small spherical bulge in front of the glabella; border furrow indistinct; fixigena wider (tr.), being approximately twice the width of the glabella between the palpebral lobes; eye ridge obliquely extending outward and slightly posteriorly from the frontal lobe of the glabella, parallel to the border furrow; palpebral lobe moderately sized, situated in a median anterior position relative to the glabella; trunk subequal to cephalon (sag.), end of pleura rounded, no pleural spine seen; pygidium relatively large, width (tr.) slightly smaller than width of cranidium (tr.).

Meraspid degree 4

Represented by two articulated specimens, with one specimen illustrated (Fig. 3C), shields of this phase range from 1.86 to 2.27 mm in length, with the thorax having four segments and the pygidial axis having five segments (m45). Cranidium semicircular, length (sag.) less than maximum width between the two palpebral lobes (tr.); glabella convex, long columnar; occipital ring convex, wider in the middle than on both sides (sag.), with a faint occipital node; librigenal spine long and slender, with the ends extending to the level of the posterior end of the pygidium; preglabellar field broad, with a spherical bulge; anterior border narrow, ca. 1/2 as long as preglabellar field (sag.); preglabellar field is broad (sag.), having a small spherical bulge; fixigena wider (tr.), being approximately twice the width of the glabella between the palpebral lobes; other characteristics are similar to those of the previous stage.

Meraspid degree 5

Represented by three articulated specimens, with one specimen illustrated (Fig. 3D), shields of this phase range from 2.09 to 2.32 mm in length, with the thorax having five segments and the pygidial axis having four segments (m54). Cranidium semicircular, length (sag.) less than width between the two palpebral lobes (tr.); glabella convex, long columnar, glabellar furrows extremely indistinct; occipital furrow shallow and straight in the middle, slightly deeper and curved forward on both sides; occipital ring wider in the middle than on both sides (sag.), with a faint occipital node; librigenal spine long and slender, extending to the level of the first pygidial segment; preglabellar field broad (sag.), with a spherical bulge; border furrow deep; fixigena wider, being approximately 1.5 times the width of the glabella between the palpebral lobes; eye ridge obliquely extending outward and slightly posteriorly from the frontal lobe of the glabella, parallel to the border furrow; palpebral lobe moderately sized, situated in a median anterior position relative to the glabella; trunk slightly longer than the cephalon (sag.), end of pleura rounded, no pleural spine seen; pygidium relatively large, width (tr.) approximately 3/4 of the width of the cranidium (tr.).

Meraspid degree 6

Represented by four articulated specimens, with one specimen illustrated (Fig. 3E), shields of this phase range from 2.50 to 2.63 mm in length, with the thorax having six segments and the pygidial axis having four segments (m64). Cranidium semicircular, length (sag.) less than width between the two palpebral lobes (tr.); glabella convex, long columnar; glabellar furrows extremely indistinct; librigenal spine long and slender, extending horizontally to the opposite end of the 6th thoracic segment; other characteristics are similar to those of the previous stage.

Meraspid degree 7

Represented by five articulated specimens, with one specimen illustrated (Fig. 3F), shields of this phase range from 2.47 to 3.06 mm in length, with the thorax having seven segments and the pygidial axis having four segments (m74). Cranidium semicircular; glabella convex, long columnar, with three pairs of fuzzy lateral glabellar furrows; occipital ring crescent-shaped, with sides curved forward and with a faint occipital node; librigenal spine long and slender; preglabellar field broad (sag.), with a spherical bulge; anterior border narrow and gently convex, ca. 1/2 as long as the preglabellar field (sag.); fixigena wider (tr.), being approximately 1.5 times the width of the glabella between the palpebral lobes; eye ridge obliquely extending outward and slightly posteriorly from the frontal lobe of the glabella, parallel to the border furrow; palpebral lobe moderately sized, situated in a median anterior position relative to the glabella; trunk slightly longer than the cephalon (sag.), pleural spine curved backward at the end of the pleura; pygidium relatively large, width (tr.) approximately 1/2 the width of the cranidium (tr.).

Meraspid degree 8

Represented by five articulated specimens, with three specimens illustrated (Fig. 3G–I), shields of this phase range from 2.67 to 3.50 mm in length, with the thorax having eight segments and the pygidial axis having four segments (m84). Cranidium semicircular, length (sag.) less than width between the two palpebral lobes (tr.); glabella convex, truncate-conical, with three pairs of lateral glabellar furrows; occipital ring crescent-shaped, with sides curved forward and with a faint occipital node; beneath the glabella lies an ovoid and natant hypostome; librigenal spine long and slender, with the ends extending to the level of the posterior end of the pygidium; preglabellar field broad (sag.), with a spherical bulge; anterior border narrow (sag.) and gently convex, ca. 1/2 as long as the preglabellar field (sag.); border furrow deep; fixigena wider (tr.), being approximately 1.5 times the width of the glabella between the palpebral lobes; palpebral lobe moderately sized, situated in a median position relative to the glabella; trunk subequal to the cephalon (sag.), pleural spine curved backward at the end of the pleura; pygidium relatively large, width (tr.) approximately 2/5 the width of the cranidium (tr.).

Meraspid degree 9

Represented by five articulated specimens, with one specimen illustrated (Fig. 3J), shields of this phase range from 2.92 to 3.91 mm in length, with the thorax having nine segments and the pygidial axis having three segments (m93). Cranidium trapezoidal, length (sag.) less than width between the two palpebral lobes (tr.); glabella convex, truncate-conical, with three pairs of lateral glabellar furrows, S3 extending diagonally near the occipital furrow; occipital furrow shallow and straight in the middle, slightly deeper and curved forward on both sides; occipital ring crescent-shaped, with sides curved forward and a faint occipital node; pygidium relatively small, transverse width equal to or slightly greater than the width of the base of the glabella; other characteristics are similar to those of the previous stage.

Meraspid degree 10

Represented by nine articulated specimens, with two specimens illustrated (Fig. 3K, L), shields of this phase range from 3.55 to 4.31 mm in length, with the thorax having 10 segments and the pygidial axis having three segments (m103). Cranidium trapezoidal, length (sag.) less than width between the two palpebral lobes (tr.); glabella convex, truncate-conical, with three pairs of lateral glabellar furrows; occipital ring crescent-shaped, with sides curved forward and with a faint occipital node; librigenal spine long and slender, extending horizontally to the opposite end of the 9th thoracic segment; preglabellar field broad (sag.), with a spherical bulge; pygidium relatively small, transverse width equal to the width of the base of the glabella.

Meraspid degree 11

Represented by 13 articulated specimens, with two specimens illustrated (Fig. 3M, N), shields of this phase range from 3.61 to 5.70 mm in length, with the thorax having 11 segments and the pygidial axis having three segments (m113). Cranidium trapezoidal, length (sag.) less than width between the two palpebral lobes (tr.); glabella convex, truncate-conical, with three pairs of lateral glabellar furrows; librigenal spine long and slender, with the ends extending to the level of the posterior end of the pygidium; fixigena wider (tr.), being approximately 1.5 times the width of the glabella between the palpebral lobes; palpebral lobe moderately sized, situated in a median position relative to the glabella; occipital ring crescent-shaped, with sides curved forward and with a faint occipital node; opisthoparian suture; trunk subequal in length to the cephalon (sag.), pleural spine curved backward at the end of the pleura; pygidium relatively small, width (tr.) slightly smaller than the width of the base of the glabella.

Meraspid degree 12

Represented by 11 articulated specimens, with three specimens illustrated (Fig. 5A–C), shields of this phase range from 4.24 to 6.02 mm in length, with the thorax having 12 segments and the pygidial axis having three segments (m123). Cranidium trapezoidal, length (sag.) less than width between the two palpebral lobes (tr.); glabella convex, truncate-conical, with three pairs of lateral glabellar furrows; librigenal spine long and slender, extending horizontally to the opposite end of the 10th thoracic segment; palpebral lobe moderately sized, situated in a median position relative to the glabella; opisthoparian suture; trunk slightly longer than the cephalon (sag.); pygidium relatively small, width (tr.) slightly smaller than the width of the base of the glabella.

Meraspid degree 13

Represented by 15 articulated specimens, with three specimens illustrated (Fig. 5D–F), shields of this phase range from 3.57 to 9.39 mm in length, with the thorax having 13 segments and the pygidial axis having three segments (m133). Cranidium trapezoidal, length (sag.) less than width between the two palpebral lobes (tr.); glabella convex, truncate-conical, with three pairs of lateral glabellar furrows; occipital lobe wider in the middle than on both sides (sag.), with a faint occipital node; genal spines long and slender, extending horizontally to the opposite end of the 9th thoracic segment; preglabellar field broad (sag.), with a spherical bulge; anterior border narrow (sag.) and gently convex, ca. 1/2 as long as the preglabellar field (sag.); palpebral lobe moderately sized, situated in a median position relative to the glabella; opisthoparian suture; pygidium relatively small, width (tr.) smaller than the width of the base of the glabella.

Holaspid period

Represented by 70 articulated specimens, with six specimens illustrated (Fig. 5G–L), shields of this phase range from 4.882 to 18.480 mm in length, with the thorax having 14 segments and the pygidial axis having two segments (m142). Detailed morphological descriptions are given in the previous section on systematic paleontology.

Summary of ontogenetic morphological variation

Yuan and Zhao (1994) systematically described Kaotaia and pointed out that, in the ontogenetic sequence of Kaotaia transversa, the main morphological variations were concentrated in the glabella, palpebral lobe, anterior border, and pygidium. This paper describes the successive ontogenetic sequence of Kaotaia globosa from meraspid degree 3 to the holaspid period, and the main trends in exoskeletal changes during ontogeny are summarized below.

  1. The length of the exoskeleton (sag.) of Kaotaia globosa ranges from a minimum of 1.53 mm in meraspid degree 3 to a maximum of 18.48 mm in the holaspid period.
  2. The outline of the glabella varies during ontogeny, from elongated in early meraspid degrees to relatively shorter and wider in the holaspid period.
  3. The relative width of the fixigena (tr.) decreases from approximately twice the width of the glabella in meraspid degree 3 to 2/3 of the width of the glabella in the holaspid period.
  4. From meraspid degree 3 to the holaspid period, the palpebral lobe length gradually decreases relative to the cranidium length. The midpoint of the palpebral lobe migrates from a position opposite the anterior of the glabellar midpoint in forms below meraspid degree 9 to opposite the glabellar midpoint from meraspid degree 9 onward.
  5. In meraspid degrees 3–8, the ends of the thoracic pleurae are rounded and blunt, and no thoracic pleural spine is present. In contrast, after meraspid degree 9, short and thick, sickle-shaped, posteriorly curved thoracic pleural spines appear at the thoracic pleural terminus.
  6. Relative to the cephalon, the pygidial width (tr.) is slightly smaller in meraspid degree 3 but decreases to equal or less than the width at the base of the glabella by the holaspid period. Based on existing measurements, the maximum length (sag.) of the pygidium during the meraspid degree 3 is 0.46 mm, whereas during the holaspid period, it is 1.29 mm.

Quantifying morphological changes in the cranidium during ontogeny

Based on the morphological descriptions of the developmental stages provided in the preceding section, the ontogenetic sequence of Kaotaia globosa is divided into three stages: meraspid degrees 3–8, meraspid degrees 9–13, and the holaspid period. To facilitate a visual analysis of the morphological changes occurring in the cranidium of K. globosa during ontogeny, 19 landmark points were extracted, and principal component analysis (PCA) was performed (Fig. 6). Thin-plate spline analysis, canonical variate analysis (CVA), analysis of similarities (ANOSIM), and allometric growth curves were also employed to identify the morphological differences between the three developmental stages and test their significance (see Suppl. material 3).

Figure 6. 

Principal component analysis (PCA) based on 19 cranidial landmark points in Kaotaia globosa. A. Scatter plot of the first principal component (y-axis) vs. the second principal component (x-axis); B. Scatter plot of the first principal component (y-axis) vs. the third principal component (x-axis). The plots showing the deformation grids, as indicated by the arrow, are located at the extreme negative and positive values of each axis.

Because the landmark data of different developmental stages of the same species were statistically analyzed, the total proportion of the first three principal components was only 53.73%. Among them, PC1 accounts for 29.81% of the variance and is primarily associated with variation in the anterior branch of the facial suture and the anterior border (Fig. 6A). Positive scores along PC1 are associated with the anterior branch of the facial suture converging toward the sagittal axis and the anterior border protruding anteriorly. Conversely, negative scores are associated with a posteriorly and laterally extending anterior branch of the facial suture and a retracted anterior border. PC2 explains 13.02% of the variance and is primarily related to the glabella and the occipital ring (Fig. 6A). Positive scores along PC2 correspond to a narrower and more elongated glabella (sag.) combined with a shorter occipital ring (tr.). Conversely, negative scores are associated with a shorter and thicker glabella (sag.) and an elongated occipital ring (tr.). The vast majority of samples from meraspid degrees 3–8 were concentrated on the positive half of the PC2 axis. PC3 accounts for 10.90% of the variance; however, the relative warps visualized through vector and thin-plate spline transformation grids exhibit a disordered state. This may suggest that such shape deformation is not of biological origin but rather stems from either mild tectonic or compression-related deformation.

As with the preceding traditional description of ontogeny, the findings based on geometric morphometrics indicate that alterations in the cranidium are predominantly attributable to morphological modifications in the facial suture, palpebral lobe, and glabella across the various stages of ontogeny in Kaotaia globosa. From the overlapping areas in the scatter plots of the first and second principal components, the meraspid degrees 3–8 and the holaspid period have almost no overlap, whereas the meraspid degrees 9–13 are almost completely covered by the other two stages (Fig. 6A). In the scatter plot of the first and third principal components, the stages overlap almost completely without any distinct boundaries (Fig. 6B). Setting the constraint value to 4, as required for correctly calculating the p-value of Procrustes-fitted landmark data, resulted in a multivariate analysis of variance (MANOVA) showing that the Wilks’ lambda value was 0.07359 (df1 = 68, df2 = 216, F = 8.533, p-value = 3.487E-34) and the Pillai trace value was 1.42 (df1 = 68, df2 = 218, F = 7.856, p-value = 7.174E-32). These values indicate significant differences between groups (p < 0.05).

Developmental mode

Based on the detailed description of the ontogenetic sequence of Kaotaia globosa in the previous section, a trunk segmentation schedule of K. globosa was drawn (Fig. 7). In general, the number of meraspid pygidial segments in K. globosa showed a decreasing trend with a gradual increase in the number of thoracic segments during ontogeny, with a total of three stages of decrease. In meraspid degrees 3–4, the number of pygidial segments was five; in meraspid degrees 5–8, the number of pygidial segments was four; in meraspid degrees 9–13, the number of pygidial segments was three; and in the holaspid period, only two pygidial segments were identified. During the holaspid period, K. globosa exhibited a consistent total number of trunk segments with the last meraspid degree (meraspid degree 13), except that the exoskeletal length increased from 4.88 to 18.48 mm. Therefore, the onset of the epimorphic stage of K. globosa is earlier than that of the holaspid period, and its mode of development is protomeric (hypoprotomeric; Hughes et al. 2006).

Figure 7. 

The proposed trunk segmentation schedule of Kaotaia globosa exhibits a range of morphs from meraspid degree 3 (m35) to the holaspid period (m142). Different morphological conditions are indicated as mxy, where x is the number of thoracic segments and y is the number of pygidial segments. Abbreviations: Epi., epimorphic; Hol., holaspid; m, morph.

Trunk growth gradients

In this study, the absolute and relative growth rates of the thoracic segments of Kaotaia globosa were calculated using the computational method proposed by Fusco et al. (2012, 2014). The average per-molt growth rate showed a gradually increasing growth gradient from the first to the 13th thoracic segment, which was abnormally high at the 13th thoracic segment (Fig. 8A); the allometry coefficient in relation to segment length also showed an increasing trend but slightly decreased at the 3rd and 12th thoracic segments (Fig. 8B). In addition, in the allometry coefficient of K. globosa, thoracic segments 1 to 7 showed a negative allometry coefficient (all. c. < 1), and thoracic segments 8 to 13 showed a positive allometry coefficient (all. c. > 1).

Figure 8. 

Growth gradient in the trunk segments of Kaotaia globosa. A. Gradient of the average per-molt segmental growth rate (absolute growth rate); B. Gradient of the segmental allometry coefficient (relative growth rate). The bars represent the standard error of the mean. Abbreviation: LTSi, ith thoracic segment.

Segment growth control mechanism

In two distinct mechanisms governing segmental growth, the segmental gradient hypothesis (SGH) proposes that individual body segments grow autonomously at constant rates, whereas the trunk gradient hypothesis (TGH) suggests that growth is controlled by a continuous gradient along the entire trunk (Fusco et al. 2012, 2014). To determine what controlled the growth of the segments of Kaotaia globosa and how well it fits with the two hypotheses (SGH or TGH), the growth trends of the segments of K. globosa were plotted using the RLS values for each developmental stage and the calculated values obtained by introducing TGexp, SGgmp, and SGpwp (Fig. 9).

Figure 9. 

Distribution curves of relative thoracic segment lengths for each thoracic segment at different developmental stages of Kaotaia globosa. A. Distribution curve based on observed values; B. Distribution curve based on values fitted to the TGexp model; C. Distribution curve based on values fitted to the SGgmp model; D. Distribution curve based on values fitted to the SGpwp model. Abbreviations: ix, the xth thoracic segment; D, developmental stage; RLS, the length of the thoracic segment relative to the trunk.

The trend plot of segment growth in Kaotaia globosa (Fig. 9A), based on the estimated value of segment length relative to trunk length (RLS), shows that the relative segment length (RLS) gradually decreases during ontogeny, and the RLS also shows a decreasing trend from anterior to posterior during the same developmental stage. The mechanism of segment growth control is consistent with the trunk gradient hypothesis (TGH), and this specific posterior-to-anterior decaying trajectory of the growth gradient is detected in K. globosa, suggesting graded signal control in its development. To further test whether the segmental growth of K. globosa is consistent with the control mechanism of the TGH and the fit to the SGH, two growth models of the SGH (SGgmp and SGpwp) and two growth models of the TGH (TGexp and TGpwl) were fitted to K. globosa (Fig. 9B–D). Based on the predictions of the different growth models and the actual measurements of the segment data, the fits of the SGgmp, SGpwp, and TGexp models were 0.915632, 0.916207, and 0.975137, respectively, while the TGpwl model failed, and the growth curves fit the exponential function equation with the higher r-value: TGexp(x) = 0.274915*e-3.57564*(1-x).

Discussion

Micropygous body pattern

In the hemianamorphic development exhibited by trilobites (Minelli et al. 2003), the developmental mode of an individual can be classified as hypoprotomeric, synarthromeric, or protarthrous, based on whether it enters the epimorphic phase during the meraspid period, at the transition to the holaspid period, or after the onset of the holaspid period, respectively (Hughes et al. 2006). Based on a summary of the developmental modes of 39 trilobites and an assessment of environmental context, the three aforementioned developmental modes occur with similar frequency in deeper waters; however, the protomeric (hypoprotomeric) developmental mode overwhelmingly predominates in shallow waters, and this predominance may be attributable to abiotic factors (Fusco et al. 2012). As highlighted by Hughes et al. (2006), developmental mode varies widely among trilobites. Even within the same taxonomic group, different species exhibit variation. For example, Ctenopyge (Eoctenopyge) angusta and C. gracilis follow a protomeric developmental mode, whereas C. (C.) ceciliae follows a protarthrous developmental mode. Early Cambrian corynexochid trilobites exhibit distinct developmental modes (Du et al. 2019). Similarly, among trilobites traditionally assigned to the “ptychopariid” taxa, the developmental mode of the solenopleurid Sao hirsuta has been interpreted as hypoprotomeric (Laibl et al. 2014), whereas the alokistocarid Elrathia kingii exhibits a synarthromeric developmental mode (Hopkins 2020). As the onset of the epimorphic stage in Kaotaia globosa precedes the holaspid period, its developmental mode is protomeric (hypoprotomeric). Trilobite developmental mode exhibits a significant phylogenetic signal (Fusco et al. 2012), and this diversity may, to some extent, reflect the phylogenetic polyphyly observed in trilobites.

In the ontogenetic sequence of the redlichiid Bathynotus kueichouensis, the number of pygidial segments during meraspid degrees 1–11 is three (excluding the terminal piece; the same applies below), but subsequently decreases in the late meraspid degrees (M12, 13) to two, the number maintained in the holaspid period (Zhang et al. 2022; Dai et al. 2023). In contrast, the number of pygidial segments in Zhangshania typica was two from meraspid degrees 2–13, with a gradual increase in the number of pygidial segments observed after entering the holaspid period; it was thus protarthrous in its development (Hou et al. 2017). The reduction in the number of meraspid pygidial segments observed in Kaotaia globosa differs from that seen in B. kueichouensis. In K. globosa, a three-stage decrease was evident throughout the ontogenetic sequence, whereas in B. kueichouensis, this decrease was concentrated in the late meraspid degrees. In Z. typica, the number of pygidial segments continued to increase even after the thoracic segments stabilized. Conversely, in K. globosa, the number of pygidial segments remains unchanged following attainment of the holaspid period.

The body proportions of trilobites vary among different species. Based on a growth model generated from extensive body size data for Aulacopleura koninckii, Hopkins (2020) suggested that depressing the growth gradient during the holaspid period yields body proportions that result in micropygous trilobites. In all or most redlichiid taxa with a micropygous body pattern, the relative size of the meraspid pygidium is maintained by producing and releasing segments in a 1:1 ratio (Dai et al. 2023). The results presented above indicate that the formation and addition of K. globosa segments do not occur on a one-to-one basis. During the transition from meraspid degree 4 to 5, the number of trunk segments does not increase; instead, one segment is released from the pygidium into the thorax. Similarly, the number of trunk segments remains unchanged during the transition from meraspid degree 8 to 9 and from meraspid degree 13 to the holaspid period (Fig. 7). This ultimately reduces the number of pygidial segments of K. globosa from five in the early meraspid period to two in the holaspid period. As the number of meraspid pygidial segments decreases, the pygidial relative width of K. globosa gradually decreases from slightly less than the width of the cephalon (tr.) in meraspid degree 3 to a width that is equal to or less than the width of the base of the glabella (tr.) in the holaspid period.

Morphometric analysis reveals changes in growth gradients

Growth gradients are reflected in differences in growth rates between organs or parts along the axis of an organism (Huxley 1932; Fusco et al. 2014), and studying the growth gradient of trilobite segments can help reveal patterns of segmental growth and development, as well as potential control mechanisms. In this study, the growth gradient of Kaotaia globosa segments was analyzed through the ontogenetic measurement data from meraspid degree 3 to the holaspid period. The calculated absolute and relative growth rates indicate that K. globosa also exhibits an increasing growth gradient toward the posterior part of the trunk (Fig. 8). The absolute growth rate of the trunk segment of K. globosa demonstrates a pronounced increase in the 13th segment (Fig. 8A), and this phenomenon is also observed in the 16th segment of Aulacopleura koninckii and Changaspis elongata (Fusco et al. 2014; Du et al. 2019).

In this paper, the absolute growth rate of trunk segments in Kaotaia globosa is expressed as the antilogarithm of the calculated value of the average incremental growth rate per molt. Notably, holaspid specimens constitute a disproportionately large fraction of the sample (70 of 145), far exceeding any meraspid degree. This prompted the question of whether the apparent increase in absolute growth rate could be correlated with sample-size disparity across stages. To investigate this, the holaspid period data were randomly subsampled, retaining only 20 specimens. Recalculation showed that the absolute growth rate of the 13th thoracic segment remained significantly elevated. During the holaspid period of K. globosa, the smallest specimen had an exoskeletal length of 4.88 mm, whereas the largest specimen reached 18.48 mm, an almost fourfold difference. Taking this into account, the data were reanalyzed after removing the measurements of larger holaspid period specimens, finding that the absolute growth rate curve tended to rise steadily. Meanwhile, the absolute growth rate of the 13th thoracic segment declined from 1.69 to 1.19 after adjustment, comparable to that of the 12th segment. To test the generality of this relationship between absolute growth rate and body length range within the holaspid period, the segmental data for Aulacopleura koninckii published by Fusco et al. (2014) were reanalyzed. After excluding holaspid period specimens exceeding 7 mm in length, the absolute growth rate of the 16th segment decreased from 1.21 to 1.05 (see Suppl. material 2 for details). This result is consistent with the pattern observed in K. globosa. Therefore, it is hypothesized that the abrupt increase in the absolute growth rate of the 13th thoracic segment in K. globosa is attributable to the substantially larger range of exoskeleton length observed during the holaspid period than in any of the meraspid stages.

Although collection biases are recognized, the number of Kaotaia globosa specimens from the early meraspid degree analyzed in this paper is significantly lower than that from the late meraspid degree and the holaspids—a pattern also observed in other trilobite ontogenetic studies (e.g., Fusco et al. 2014; Hughes et al. 2017; Du et al. 2019). Fortunately, Dai et al. (2021a) provided a wealth of body length data for early meraspid degree specimens of Oryctocarella duyunensis, which made it possible to assess the impact of morphometric analysis when the number of specimens is limited. After artificially and randomly reducing the early meraspid degree data of O. duyunensis, changes in the growth gradients and the estimated values of segmental growth trends under different model fits were only minimally affected. High-quality, abundant ontogenetic series can minimize the impact on descriptive statistics and hypothesis testing (Fusco et al. 2012). However, given the scope of the current work, this requirement has not yet been met, and further work in this area is necessary.

Gradually increasing growth gradient accelerated the construction of trilobite body size

A recent study suggested that changes in the body size of Cambrian–Ordovician trilobites were closely related to marine redox fluctuations and that larger-bodied animals may have been more susceptible to impact during biological crises (Sun et al. 2025). Trilobites achieved growth through molting behavior (Daley and Drage 2016; Drage et al. 2018); the presence of larger individuals in the holaspid period suggests that molting behavior continues throughout their life cycle (Henningsmoen 1975). Unfortunately, complete ontogenies have only been reported for a few species. Most of these show a significant difference in exoskeletal length between the smallest and largest holaspid stages (Fig. 10). Some individuals of Elrathia kingii experienced a 7.5-fold increase in exoskeletal length during the holaspid period, and assuming that the cephalic growth rate remains constant, E. kingii would need to undergo at least 28 molts to achieve its maximum body length (Hopkins 2021). Since the absolute growth rate of the 13th thoracic segment is greatly influenced by the size range of the holaspid period (see above), and assuming that the rate remains constant throughout subsequent ontogeny, the absolute growth rate of the 12th segment (1.34) was used to estimate the minimum number of molts required for K. globosa to achieve its maximum exoskeletal size. The results show that K. globosa would have experienced at least five molts from the smallest holaspid specimen (4.88 mm) to the largest holaspid specimen (18.48 mm) when growing at this rate. Although growth rates vary among different species, trilobites with greater ranges in exoskeletal length will, in general, require more molting cycles to attain their maximum size.

Figure 10. 

Distribution of holaspid exoskeletal lengths in five orders of articulated trilobites. The exoskeletal length range of E. intermediata (5.82–57.89 mm), data from Dai and Zhang (2013b); B. kueichouensis (2.72–63.55 mm), data from Zhang et al. (2022); Z. typica (4.53–85 mm), data from Hou et al. (2017); W. malungensis (5–37 mm), data from Luo et al. (2015); E. bilobata (5.04–31.34 mm), data from Holmes et al. (2021b); S. changyangensis (3.1–7.6 mm), data from Dai and Zhang (2013a); P. vinusta (1.27–6.01 mm), data from Cui et al. (2019); T. yanjiazhaiensis (2.91–4.95 mm), data from Dai et al. (2016); T. acutus (2.2–6.6 mm), data from Dai and Zhang (2011); D. duodingensis (3–6.01 mm), data from Hou et al. (2015); D. duyunensis (3.58–6.96 mm), data from Dai et al. (2017); O. duyunensis (4.55–10.2 mm), data from Dai et al. (2021b); O. indicus (12–25 mm), data from Esteve et al. (2017); C. elongata (17.73–21.1 mm), data from Du et al. (2019); A. chauveaui (6.32–13.03 mm), data from Du et al. (2020); E. kingii (4.9–36.8 mm), data from Hopkins (2021); P. scarabaeoides (5.75–13 mm), data from Bird and Clarkson (2003); A. koninckii (13.32–28.81 mm), data from Hughes et al. (2017). The classification criteria for the order are principally derived from the scheme proposed by Fortey (1997). The present study does not address the systematic classification of different genera and species. Statistical analysis of trilobites was based on articulated specimens, with the last meraspid degree determined following the respective original descriptions in published articles.

Here, the holaspid exoskeletal lengths of articulated trilobites across five orders were analyzed using previously published data (Fig. 10). This result cannot fully represent the exact growth of a particular trilobite because of factors such as the uncertainty of fossil specimen preservation, differences in the degree of research, and survivor bias. Nevertheless, this compilation shows that most holaspid trilobites encompass a wide range of sizes. Based on substantial differences observed in size distribution between the pre-holaspid and holaspid periods, Dai et al. (2023) proposed that the holaspid period constitutes the majority of the life cycle of certain trilobite species. The gradually increasing anterior-to-posterior growth gradient observed in Kaotaia globosa and several other species appears to confirm the hypothesis proposed by Dai et al. (2023). In other words, the increasing growth gradient enables the number of trunk segments to reach a stable state within a relatively short period (i.e., shorter anamorphic development), after which prolonged epimorphic development continues to increase the body size of trilobites.

The sexual maturity and sexual dimorphism of trilobites

Arthropod phylogeny suggests that sexual dimorphism was probably widespread among Trilobita (Hughes and Fortey 1995). However, the specific features that effectively distinguish dimorphism vary to some extent among different trilobites. Several studies have proposed various potential indicators, including numerical ratio, relative size, and exoskeletal ornamentation (Hu 1971); the number and morphology of macropleural segments (Gozalo et al. 2003); the spherical enrolled shape (Cederström et al. 2009); and the presence or absence of pygidial margin spines (Lei et al. 2023). Specifically, Fortey and Hughes (1998) proposed that a spherical bulge on the preglabellar field in several trilobites functioned as a brood pouch. Interestingly, features reminiscent of some proposed dimorphic traits are observed in two closely related trilobites from the Kaili Formation. Kaotaia globosa and K. magna are highly similar, with one of the primary distinctions being a more pronounced preglabellar bulge in K. globosa (Zhang et al. 1980). Noting that K. globosa possesses a preglabellar bulge almost as prominent as that of Parabolinella bolbifrons, Fortey and Hughes (1998) proposed that K. globosa and K. magna may represent manifestations of sexual dimorphism. Although they share the same stratigraphic range in the Miaobanpo section, their recorded frequencies differ considerably (approximately 7:1) based on existing collections. Moreover, there is no evidence that trunk segment stabilization in trilobites is linked to sexual maturity (Hughes et al. 2006). Critically, the preglabellar bulge in K. globosa is clearly present from as early as meraspid degree 8—five instars before the holaspid phase. Taken together, these observations suggest that sexual maturity at this early developmental stage is highly unlikely; instead, the preglabellar bulge in K. globosa is more parsimoniously interpreted as a species-specific ontogenetic feature rather than a reproductive adaptation.

Conclusion

The substantial quantity of articulated Kaotaia globosa specimens from the Kaili Formation in Guizhou Province provides unique opportunities to characterize its ontogenetic changes both qualitatively and quantitatively. Traditional morphological descriptions and geometric morphometric analyses reveal gradual changes in cranidium shape, while morphometric analyses of different ontogenetic stages indicate that the trunk growth pattern of K. globosa is consistent with regional growth control. The discovery of this anterior-to-posterior increasing growth-gradient trajectory in K. globosa suggests that its growth control mechanism depends on positional specification and differential growth along the body axis. Analysis of segmental growth further shows that the apparent abrupt increase in the absolute growth rate of the posteriormost thoracic segment is likely exaggerated by the exceptionally broad size range of holaspid specimens. However, when taphonomic or sampling bias is accounted for, a progressively increasing posterior growth gradient remains evident and aligns with patterns reported in other trilobite groups. This mechanism may have enabled trilobites to rapidly establish their fundamental body architecture during ontogeny, while permitting prolonged epimorphic development to continue increasing body size.

Acknowledgements

This work was supported by the National Natural Science Foundation of China (42262003, 42330209, and 42162005) and the Guizhou Science and Technology Fund (Gui. Sci. Bas. ZD [2025]100, Gui. Sci. Plat. ZSYS [2024]002). Sincere thanks are extended to Nigel C. Hughes, Lukáš Laibl, and the anonymous reviewer for their valuable feedback, and special gratitude is extended to editors Allison C. Daley, Daniel Marty, and Harriet B. Drage for their guidance and support.

References

  • Álvaro JJ, Esteve J, Zamora S (2018) Morphological assessment of the earliest paradoxidid trilobites (Cambrian Series 3) from Morocco and Spain. Geological Magazine 155(7): 1566–1595. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0016756817000449
  • Bird C, Clarkson ENK (2003) Observations on the ontogeny of the upper Cambrian trilobite Peltura scarabaeoides westergaardi Henningsmoen, 1957. GFF 125(4): 177–190. https://doi.org/10.1080/11035890301254177
  • Cederström P, Ahlberg P, Clarkson ENK, Nilsson CH, Axheimer N (2009) The lower Cambrian eodiscoid trilobite Calodiscus lobatus from Sweden: morphology, ontogeny and distribution. Palaeontology 52(3): 491–539. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1475-4983.2009.00858.x
  • Chatterton BDE (1980) Ontogenetic studies of Middle Ordovician trilobites from the Esbataottine Formation, Mackenzie Mountains, Canada. Palaeontogr. Abteilung A Palaozool. Stratigr 171: 1–74.
  • Chen SG, Yang XL, Liu X, Chen ZP, Sun ZX, Zhao FC (2023) Moulting behaviour in the trilobite Oryctocephalus indicus (Reed, 1910) from the Cambrian Miaolingian Series (Wuliuan Stage) of Jianhe, South China. PeerJ 11: e16440. http://doi.org/10.7717/peerj.16440
  • Chen ZP, Zhao YL, Yang XL, Esteve J, Liu X, Chen SG, Feng R (2022) Interspecies and intraspecific variability in the trilobites Duyunaspis and Balangia from the Cambrian Series 2 (Stage 4) of Jianhe, South China. Lethaia 55: 1–13. https://doi.org/10.18261/let.55.4.5
  • Crônier C, Bignon A, Francois A (2011) Morphological and ontogenetic criteria for defining a trilobite species: The example of Siluro-Devonian Phacopidae. Comptes rendus Palevol 10: 143–153. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.crpv.2010.10.003
  • Cui LH, Dal T, Zhang XL, Peng SC (2019) Morphology and ontogeny of the eodiscoid trilobite Pagetia vinusta from the Cambrian (Miaolingian) of South China. Paläontologische Zeitschrift 93(2): 195–206. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12542-018-00446-7
  • Dai T, Zhang XL (2013b) Ontogeny of the redlichiid trilobite Eoredlichia intermediata from the Chengjiang Lagerstätte, lower Cambrian, southwest China. Lethaia 46(2): 262–273. https://doi.org/10.1111/let.12002
  • Dai T, Zhang XL, Peng SC (2016) Morphology and development of the eodiscoid trilobite Tsunyidiscus yanjiazhaiensis from the Cambrian (Stage 3, Series 2) of South China. Journal of Systematic Palaeontology 14(1): 75–89. https://doi.org/10.1080/14772019.2015.1005699
  • Dai T, Zhang XL, Peng SC, Yao XY (2017) Intraspecific variation of segmentation in the oryctocephalid trilobite Duyunaspis duyunensis from the Cambrian (Stage 4, Series 2) of South China. Lethaia 50(4): 527–539. https://doi.org/10.1111/let.12208
  • Dai T, Hughes NC, Zhang XL, Fusco G (2021a) Absolute axial growth and trunk segmentation in the early Cambrian trilobite Oryctocarella duyunensis. Paleobiology 47(3): 517–532. https://doi.org/10.1017/pab.2020.63
  • Dai T, Hughes NC, Zhang XL, Peng SC (2021b) Development of the early Cambrian oryctocephalid trilobite Oryctocarella duyunensis from western Hunan, China. Journal of Paleontology 95(4): 777–792. https://doi.org/10.1017/jpa.2020.111
  • Dai T, Zhang XL, Peng SC (2023) Developmental traits and life strategy of redlichiid trilobites. Biological Reviews 98(1): 63–80. https://doi.org/10.1111/brv.12895
  • Delabroye A, Crônier C (2008) Ontogeny of an Ordovician Trinucleid (Trilobita) from Armorica, France: a morphometric approach. Journal of Paleontology 82(4): 800–810. https://doi.org/10.1666/07-084.1
  • Drage HB, Holmes JD, Garcia-Bellido DC, Daley AC (2018) An exceptional record of Cambrian trilobite moulting behaviour preserved in the Emu Bay Shale, South Australia. Lethaia 51(4): 473–492. https://doi.org/10.1111/let.12266
  • Du GY, Peng J, Wang DZ, Wang QJ, Wang YF, Zhang H (2019) Morphology and developmental traits of the trilobite Changaspis elongata from the Cambrian Series 2 of Guizhou, South China. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 64(4): 797–813. https://doi.org/10.4202/app.00604.2019
  • Du GY, Peng J, Wang DZ, Wen RQ, Liu S (2020) Morphology and trunk development of the trilobite Arthricocephalus chauveaui from the Cambrian Series 2 of Guizhou, South China. Historical Biology 32(2): 174–186. https://doi.org/10.1080/08912963.2018.1476857
  • Esteve J (2012) Intraspecific variability in paradoxidid trilobites from the Purujosa trilobite assemblage (middle Cambrian, northeast Spain). Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 59(1): 215–240. https://doi.org/10.4202/app.2012.0006
  • Esteve J, Zhao YL, Peng J (2017) Morphological assessment of the Cambrian trilobites Oryctocephalus indicus (Reed 1910) from China and Oryctocephalus ‘reticulatus’ (Lermontova 1940) from Siberia. Lethaia 50(1): 175–193. https://doi.org/10.1111/let.12185
  • Feng ZZ, Peng YM, Jin ZK, Bao ZD (2004) Lithofacies paleogeography of the Cambrian and Ordovician in China. Petroleum Industry Press, Beijing, 233 pp. [in Chinese]
  • Fortey RA (1997) Classification. In: Kaesler RL (Ed.) Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology, Part O. Arthropoda 1. Trilobita (Revised). Geological Society of America and University of Kansas Press, 289–302.
  • Fortey RA, Chatterton BDE (1988) Classification of the trilobite suborder Asaphina. Palaeontology 31: 165–222.
  • Fortey RA, Owens RM (1991) A trilobite fauna from the highest Shineton Shales in Shropshire, and the correlation of the latest Tremadoc. Geological Magazine 128(5): 437–464. https://doi.org/10.1017/S0016756800018616
  • Fusco G, Hughes NC, Webster M, Minelli A (2004) Exploring developmental modes in a fossil arthropod: growth and trunk segmentation of the trilobite Aulacopleura konincki. The American Naturalist 163(2): 167–183. https://doi.org/10.1086/381042
  • Fusco G, Hong PS, Hughes NC (2014) Positional specification in the segmental growth pattern of an early arthropod. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 281(1781): 20133037. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2013.3037
  • Fusco G, Hong PS, Hughes NC (2016) Axial growth gradients across the postprotaspid ontogeny of the Silurian trilobite Aulacopleura koninckii. Paleobiology 42(3): 426–438. https://doi.org/10.1017/pab.2016.5
  • Gaines RR, Mering JA, Zhao YL, Peng J (2011) Stratigraphic and microfacies analysis of the Kaili Formation, a candidate GSSP for the Cambrian Series 2-Series 3 boundary. Palaeogeography Palaeoclimatology Palaeoecology 311(3–4): 171–183. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.palaeo.2011.08.018
  • Gozalo R, Liñan E, Dies ME (2003) Intraspecific dimorphism in an evolutionary series of paradoxidids from the Middle Cambrian of Murero, Spain. Special Papers in Palaeontology. In: Lane PD, Siveter DJ, Fortey RA (Eds) Trilobites and their relatives. Special Papers in Palaeontology 70: 141–156.
  • Hammer Ø, Harper DAT, Ryan PD (2001) PAST: paleontological statistics software package for education and data analysis. Palaeontologia Electronica 4: 1–9.
  • Holmes JD, Paterson JR, Garcia-Bellido DC (2021a) Complex axial growth patterns in an early Cambrian trilobite from South Australia. Proceedings of the Royal Society B 288(1965): 20212131. https://doi.org/10.1098/rspb.2021.2131
  • Holmes JD, Paterson JR, Garcia-Bellido DC (2021b) The post-embryonic ontogeny of the early Cambria trilobite Estaingia bilobate from South Australia: trunk development and phylogenetic implications. Papers in Palaeontology 7(2): 931–950. https://doi.org/10.1002/spp2.1323
  • Hong PS, Hughes NC, Sheets HD (2014) Size, shape, and systematics of the Silurian trilobite Aulacopleura koninckii. Journal of Paleontology 88(6): 1120–1138. https://doi.org/10.1666/13-142
  • Hopkins MJ (2017) Development, trait evolution, and the evolution of development in trilobites. Integrative and Comparative Biology 57: 488–498. https://doi.org/10.1093/icb/icx033
  • Hopkins MJ (2021) Ontogeny of the trilobite Elrathia kingii (Meek) and comparison of growth rates between Elrathia kingii and Aulacopleura koninckii (Barrande). Papers in Paleontology 7(2): 985–1002. https://doi.org/10.1002/spp2.1331
  • Hopkins MJ, Pearson JK (2016) Non-linear ontogenetic shape change in Cryptolithus tesselatus (Trilobita) using three-dimensional geometric morphometrics. Palaeontologia Electronica 19.3.42A: 1–54. https://doi.org/10.26879/665
  • Hou JB, Hughes NC, Lan T, Yang J, Zhang XG (2015) Early postembryonic to mature ontogeny of the oryctocephalid trilobite Duodingia duodingensis from the lower Cambrian (Series 2) of southern China. Papers in Palaeontology 1(4): 497–513. https://doi.org/10.1002/spp2.1021
  • Hou JB, Hughes NC, Yang J, Lan T, Zhang XG, Dominguez C (2017) Ontogeny of the articulated yiliangellinine trilobite Zhangshania typica from the lower Cambrian (Series 2, Stage 3) of southern China. Journal of Paleontology 91(1): 86–99. https://doi.org/10.1017/jpa.2016.118
  • Hu CH (1971) Ontogeny and sexual dimorphism of lower Paleozoic Trilobita. Palaeontographica Americana 7: 31–155.
  • Hughes NC, Fortey RA (1995) Sexual dimorphism in trilobites, with an Ordovician case study. In: Cooper JC, Droser ML, Finney SC (Eds) Ordovician Odyssey: Short Papers for the Seventh International Symposium on the Ordovician System: Los Angeles, Pacific Section Society for Sedimentary Geology, 419–421.
  • Hughes NC, Minelli A, Fusco G (2006) The ontogeny of trilobite segmentation: a comparative approach. Paleobiology 32(4): 602–627. https://doi.org/10.1666/06017.1
  • Hughes NC, Hong PS, Hou JB, Fusco G (2017) The development of the Silurian trilobite Aulacopleura koninckii reconstructed by applying inferred growth and segmentation dynamics: a case study in paleo-evo-devo. Frontiers in Ecology & Evolution 5: 00037. https://doi.org/10.3389/fevo.2017.00037
  • Hughes NC, Adrain JM, Holmes JD, Hong PS, Hopkins MJ, Hou JB, Minelli A, Park TYS, Paterson JR, Peng J, Webster M, Zhang XG, Zhang XL, Fusco G (2021) Articulated trilobite ontogeny: Suggestions for a methodological standard. Journal of Paleontology 95(2): 298–304. https://doi.org/10.1017/JPA.2020.96
  • Hunda BR, Hughes NC (2007) Evaluating paedomorphic heterochrony in trilobites: the case of the diminutive trilobite Flexicalymene retrorsa minuens from the Cincinnatian Series (Upper Ordovician), Cincinnati region. Evolution Development 9(5): 483–498. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1525-142x.2007.00186.x
  • Jackson IS, Budd GE (2017) Intraspecific morphological variation of Agnostus pisiformis, a Cambrian Series 3 trilobite-like arthropod. Lethaia 50(4): 467–485. https://doi.org/10.1111/let.12201
  • Jacobs GS, Carlucci JR (2019) Ontogeny and shape change of the phacopid trilobite Calyptaulax. Journal of Paleontology 93(6): 1105–1125. https://doi.org/10.1017/jpa.2019.38
  • Laibl L, Fatka O, Crônier C, Budil P (2014) Early ontogeny of the Cambrian trilobite Sao hirsuta from the Skryje-Týřovice Basin, Barrandian area, Czech Republic. Bulletin of Geosciences 89(2): 293–309. https://doi.org/10.3140/bull.geosci.1438
  • Laibl L, Saleh F, Pérez-Peris F (2023) Drifting with trilobites: the invasion of the early post-embryonic trilobite stages to the pelagic realm. Palaeogeography Palaeoclimatology Palaeoecology 613: 111403. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.palaeo.2023.111403
  • Lei QP (2016) New ontogenetic information on Duyunaspis duyunensis Zhang & Qian in Zhou et al., 1977 (Trilobita, Corynexochida) from the Cambrian and its possible sexual dimorphism. Alcheringa 40: 12–23. https://doi.org/10.1080/03115518.2015.1069485
  • Lei QP, Liu Q, Peng SC (2023) The trilobite Pseudoblackwelderia lubrica (Damesellidae) from the Cambrian (Guzhangian) Changhia Formation of Northern Anhui, China, and its potential sexual dimorphism. Alcheringa: An Australasian Journal of Palaeontology 47(1): 1–10. https://doi.org/10.1080/03115518.2023.2171125
  • Lin JP, Ausich W, Zhao YL (2008) Settling strategy of stalked echinoderms from the Kaili Biota (middle Cambrian), Guizhou Province, South China. Palaeogeography Palaeoclimatology Palaeoecology 258(3): 213–221. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.palaeo.2007.05.024
  • Liu X, Zhao YL, Yang XL, Chen ZP, Chen SG, Luo X (2023) Stalked eocrinoids attached onto hyolithids with helens from Cambrian Kaili Formation in Jianhe, Guizhou, South China. Palaeogeography Palaeoclimatology Palaeoecology 610: 111330. https://doi.org/10.1016/J.PALAEO.2022.111330
  • Luo HL, Yuan JL, Hu SX, Yin JY, Zhang DQ, Miao LY (2015) Ontogeny of the trilobite Wutingaspis malungensis Lu, 1961. Acta Palaeontologica Sinica 54: 1–11. [in Chinese]
  • Minelli A, Fusco G, Hughes NC (2003) Tagmata and segment specification in trilobites. Special Papers in Palaeontology 70: 31–43.
  • Paterson JR, Edgecombe GD, Lee MSY (2019) Trilobite evolutionary rates constrain the duration of the Cambrian explosion. Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences 116(10): 4394–4399. https://doi.org/10.1073/pnas.1819366116
  • Rohlf FJ (2010) tpsDig. Version 2.16. Department of Ecology and Evolution, Sate University of New York at Stony Brook.
  • Sun ZX, Zeng H, Zhao FC (2020) A new middle Cambrian trilobite with a specialized cephalon from Shandong Province, North China. Acta Palaeontologica Polonica 65(4): 709–718. https://doi.org/10.4202/app.00753.2020
  • Sun ZX, Zhao FC, Zeng H, Erwin DH, Zhu MY (2025) Episodic body size variations of early Paleozoic trilobites associated with marine redox changes. Science advances 11(18): eadt7572. https://doi.org/10.1126/sciadv.adt7572
  • Wang Y, Lin JP, Zhao YL, Orr PJ (2009) Palaeoecology of the trace fossil Gordia and its interaction with nonmineralizing taxa from the early Middle Cambrian Kaili Biota, Guizhou province, South China. Palaeogeography Palaeoclimatology Palaeoecology 277(1–2): 141–148. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.palaeo.2009.02.017
  • Webster M (2007b) Ontogeny and evolution of the early cambrian trilobite genus Nephrolenellus (Olenelloidea). Journal of Paleontology 81(6): 1168–1193. https://doi.org/10.1666/06-092.1
  • Webster M (2015) Ontogeny and intraspecific variation of the early Cambrian trilobite Olenellus gilberti, with implications for olenelline phylogeny and macroevolutionary trends in phenotypic canalization. Journal of Systematic Palaeontology 13(1): 1–74. https://doi.org/10.1080/14772019.2013.852903
  • Webster M, Sheets HD, Hughes NC (2001) Allometric patterning in trilobite ontogeny: testing for heterochrony in Nephrolenellus. In: Zelditch ML (Ed.) Beyond Heterochrony: The Evolution of Development. Wiley, New York, 105–144.
  • Whittington HB, Kelly SRA (1997) Morphological terms applied to Trilobita. In: Kaesler RL (Ed.) Treatise on Invertebrate Paleontology. Part O. Arthropoda 1. Trilobita (Revised). Geological Society of America and University of Kansas Press, 313–329.
  • Wu MY, LoDuca TS, Zhao YL, Xiao SH (2016) The macroalga Bosworthia from the Cambrian Burgess Shale and Kaili biotas of North America and China. Review of Palaeobotany and Palynology 230: 47–55. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.revpalbo.2016.04.001
  • Yin GZ (1987) Cambrian. In: Bureau of Guizhou geology and mineral resources (Ed.) Regional geology of Guizhou Province. PRC ministry of geology and mineral resource: geological memories series 1. Geological Publishing House, Beijing, 49–96. [in Chinese]
  • Yuan JL, Zhao YL (1994) On Kaotaia. Acta Palaeontologica Sinica 3: 281–294. [in Chinese]
  • Yuan JL, Zhao YL, Li Y, Huang YZ (2002) Trilobite Fauna of the Kaili Formation (Uppermost Lower Cambrian-Lower Middle Cambrian) from Southeastern Guizhou, South China. Shanghai Science and Technology Press, Shanghai, 423 pp. [in Chinese]
  • Zelditch ML, Swiderski DL, Sheets HD, Fink WL (2004) Geometric Morphometrics of Biologists: A Primer. Elsevier Academic Press, San Diego, California, 443 pp.
  • Zhang Q, Dai T, Zhang XL, Peng SC (2022) Development and trunk segmentation of a redlichiid trilobite from Cambrian series 2 of China. Lethaia 55(3): 1–19. https://doi.org/10.18261/let.55.3.5
  • Zhang WT, Lu YH, Zhu ZL, Qian YY, Lin HL, Zhou ZY, Zhang SG, Yuan JL (1980) Cambrian trilobite faunas of southwestern China. Palacontologia Sinica, Vol. 159, New Series B 16: 1–497. [in Chinese]
  • Zhang ZH, Shen JW, Gong XY, Zhao YL, Miao JR, Yan CH (1996) A preliminary discussion on preservation condition of Kaili Fauna, Middle Cambrian, Taijiang, Guizhou. Acta Palaeontologica Sinica 35: 607–622. [in Chinese]
  • Zhao YL, Peng J, Yuan JL, Babcock LE, Guo QJ, Yin LM, Yang XL, Tai TS, Wang CJ, Lin JP, Gaines RR, Sun HJ, Yang YN (2012) Discussion on the Global Standard Stratotype Section and Point (GSSP) for defining the conterminous base of Cambrian provisional Series 3 and Stage 5. In: Zhao YL, Zhu MY, Peng J, Gaines RR, Parsley RL (Eds) Cryogenian—ediacaran to cambrian stratigraphy and paleontology of Guizhou, China. Journal of Guizhou University (Natural Science) 29: 35–48. [in Chinese]
  • Zhao YL, Yuan JL, Babcock LE, Guo QJ, Peng J, Yin LM, Yang XL, Peng SC, Wang CJ, Gaines RR, Esteve J, Tai TS, Yang RD, Wang Y, Sun HJ, Yang YN (2019) Global standard stratotype-section and point (GSSP) for the conterminous base of the Miaolingian Series and Wuliuan Stage (Cambrian) at Balang, Jianhe, Guizhou, China. Episodes 42(2): 165–184. https://doi.org/10.18814/epiiugs/2019/019013
  • Zhou ZY, Yuan JL, Zhang ZH, Wu XR, Yin GZ (1979) The Cambrian bio-geographical realm divided in Guizhou Province, South China and adjacent to region. Journal of Stratigraphy 3: 258–271. [in Chinese]
  • Zhu MY, Erdtmann BD, Zhao YL (1999) Taphonomy and paleoecology of the early middle Cambrian Kaili lagerstätte in Guizhou, China. Acta Palaeontologica Sinica 38: 28–57. [in Chinese]

Additional information

Conflict of interest

The authors have declared that no competing interests exist.

Ethical statement

No ethical statement was reported.

Artificial Intelligence (AI) use

The authors accept full responsibility for the content of the manuscript, including the disclosure of any use of AI.

No AI tools were used in the preparation of this manuscript.

Funding

This work was supported by National Natural Science Foundation of China and Guizhou Science and Technology Fund.

Author contributions

Shengguang Chen conceived and designed the experiments, performed the experiments, analyzed the data, prepared figures and/or tables, authored or reviewed drafts of the article, and approved the final draft. Xinglian Yang conceived and designed the experiments, performed the experiments, analyzed the data, reviewed drafts of the article provided financial support for research, and approved the final draft. Fangchen Zhao conceived and designed the experiments, reviewed drafts of the article, and approved the final draft. Dezhi Wang conceived and designed the experiments, performed the experiments, analyzed the data, reviewed drafts of the article, and approved the final draft. Zhixin Sun reviewed drafts of the article. Zhengpeng Chen analyzed the data. All authors contributed to, or reviewed, drafts of the manuscript and approved the final version.

Author ORCIDs

S. Chen https://orcid.org/0009-0002-2063-0205

Data availability

All of the data that support the findings of this study are available in the main text or Supplementary Information.

Supplementary materials

Supplementary material 1 

Landmark point data used for analysis

Shengguang Chen, Dezhi Wang, Zhixin Sun, Zhengpeng Chen, Xinglian Yang, Fangchen Zhao

Data type: xlsx

This dataset is made available under the Open Database License (http://opendatacommons.org/licenses/odbl/1.0). The Open Database License (ODbL) is a license agreement intended to allow users to freely share, modify, and use this Dataset while maintaining this same freedom for others, provided that the original source and author(s) are credited.
Download file (104.62 kb)
Supplementary material 2 

Segmental data used for analysis

Shengguang Chen, Dezhi Wang, Zhixin Sun, Zhengpeng Chen, Xinglian Yang, Fangchen Zhao

Data type: xlsx

This dataset is made available under the Open Database License (http://opendatacommons.org/licenses/odbl/1.0). The Open Database License (ODbL) is a license agreement intended to allow users to freely share, modify, and use this Dataset while maintaining this same freedom for others, provided that the original source and author(s) are credited.
Download file (370.83 kb)
Supplementary material 3 

Supplementary document of geometric morphometrics

Shengguang Chen, Dezhi Wang, Zhixin Sun, Zhengpeng Chen, Xinglian Yang, Fangchen Zhao

Data type: xlsx

Explanation note: The data underpinning the analysis reported in this paper are deposited at GBIF, the Global Biodiversity Information Facility, and are available at https://doi.org/10.15468/rd3d8f.

This dataset is made available under the Open Database License (http://opendatacommons.org/licenses/odbl/1.0). The Open Database License (ODbL) is a license agreement intended to allow users to freely share, modify, and use this Dataset while maintaining this same freedom for others, provided that the original source and author(s) are credited.
Download file (12.83 MB)
login to comment